Conversation
Mesa DescriptionThis pull request refactors the FUSE filesystem implementation to process operations in parallel, significantly improving performance and throughput. Previously, the FUSE interface handled requests synchronously, creating a bottleneck that limited processing to one operation at a time. This PR addresses that limitation by making the following architectural changes:
Description generated by Mesa. Update settings |
5192189 to
80d432d
Compare
80d432d to
7f77235
Compare
|
/review |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Performed full review of e2d3738...c5e6915
Analysis
-
Fire-and-forget task pattern in
FuserAdapter::spawnlacks task lifecycle management, risking orphaned operations and resource leaks during unmount since FUSE reply handles can be dropped without responding. -
Global serialization bottleneck in
MescloudICache::ensure_child_inowith a single mutex that serializes ALL child inode allocations, potentially limiting parallel directory operations. -
Inconsistent synchronization patterns across inode allocation paths - while
ensure_child_inois protected, similar TOCTOU patterns exist unfixed inMesaFS::ensure_org_inode,OrgFs::ensure_owner_inode, andOrgFs::ensure_repo_inode. -
Silent error handling with multiple
insert_asynccalls discarding results (let _ = ...), masking potential race condition bugs sincescc::HashMapreturns errors on duplicate keys. -
Non-atomic bridge reset in
HashMapBridge::reset()creates a window for inconsistent state observation as it clears two maps with separate write locks.
Tip
Help
Slash Commands:
/review- Request a full code review/review latest- Review only changes since the last review/describe- Generate PR description. This will update the PR body or issue comment depending on your configuration/help- Get help with Mesa commands and configuration options
10 files reviewed | 1 comments | Edit Agent Settings • Read Docs
|
|
||
| self.composite.child_inodes.insert(ino, org_idx); | ||
| self.composite.inode_to_slot.insert(ino, org_idx); | ||
| let _ = self.composite.child_inodes.insert_async(ino, org_idx).await; |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
ensure_org_inode now runs under &self and relies on try_reuse_org_inode’s any_async scan to detect existing entries. There is no serialization between that scan and this insert/reset block, so two concurrent lookups for the same org_idx can both miss the existing inode, each allocate a fresh ino, insert separate entries here, and both call slot.bridge.reset(). Whichever request completes last wins and re-seeds the bridge with its inode, while the other inode has already been returned to the kernel and is still recorded in child_inodes/inode_to_slot but no longer has any bridge mappings. Subsequent getattr/read/readdir calls on that inode will fail because the bridge can’t translate it anymore. Please add per-org synchronization (e.g. a mutex keyed by org_idx or an entry_async that ensures only one allocator wins) so that we only create a single inode and never reset the bridge twice for the same org.
Prompt for Agent
Task: Address review feedback left on GitHub.
Repository: mesa-dot-dev/gitfs#35
File: src/fs/mescloud/mod.rs#L304
Action: Open this file location in your editor, inspect the highlighted code, and resolve the issue described below.
Feedback:
`ensure_org_inode` now runs under `&self` and relies on `try_reuse_org_inode`’s `any_async` scan to detect existing entries. There is no serialization between that scan and this insert/reset block, so two concurrent lookups for the same `org_idx` can both miss the existing inode, each allocate a fresh `ino`, insert separate entries here, and both call `slot.bridge.reset()`. Whichever request completes last wins and re-seeds the bridge with its inode, while the other inode has already been returned to the kernel and is still recorded in `child_inodes`/`inode_to_slot` but no longer has any bridge mappings. Subsequent getattr/read/readdir calls on that inode will fail because the bridge can’t translate it anymore. Please add per-org synchronization (e.g. a mutex keyed by `org_idx` or an `entry_async` that ensures only one allocator wins) so that we only create a single inode and never reset the bridge twice for the same org.
No description provided.